Should we home educate? A calm way to decide

By Carl Morris, Co-founder of Phoenix Tutors and Vice President of The Tutors' Association. Last reviewed 16 November 2026.

There is no answer that is right for every child, but there is a right order to decide in. First work out what exactly is not working at school, then what has and has not been tried, then who would teach and how you would live day to day. Home education can be a rest, a reset or a long-term choice, and it helps to know which you are choosing before you send the letter.

Who this covers. Parents in the UK whose child is on a school roll and unhappy, anxious, refusing school or not being stretched. It is not medical advice. If your child's anxiety or low mood is severe, your GP and the school remain part of the plan whatever you decide about school.

What exactly is not working?

Try to name it as precisely as you can: the place (noise, size, the journey), the people (a peer group, a teacher, bullying), the pace (too fast, too slow), or the work itself. Each has a different remedy. A child who is frightened of the corridor needs something different from a child who is bored in maths, and home education solves some of these far better than others.

What has the school tried, and what has it not?

Ask in writing for a meeting with the special educational needs coordinator or head of year, and ask what adjustments are possible: a reduced timetable for a fixed period, a quiet place to start the day, a change of class, an assessment of needs. If your child may have special educational needs, you can ask the council for an education, health and care needs assessment yourself. If your child has an EHCP, read our page on that first, because leaving school changes what the council must provide.

Is there a middle way?

Sometimes. Flexi-schooling, where a child attends part time and is educated at home the rest of the week, is something a school can agree to but is under no obligation to, so you cannot insist on it. A change of school can also be a better answer than leaving school altogether when the problem is the place or the people.

What do we give up if we deregister?

The school place: if you change your mind you apply again, and the school may be full. Exams arranged and paid for by the school: home educated children sit GCSEs as private candidates and families pay the fees. Any support the school was providing. None of this is a reason not to do it, but it is better known before than after.

Who would teach, and what would a week look like?

You do not need to be a teacher, follow the National Curriculum or keep school hours. You do need a realistic plan for who is with your child, who covers the subjects you cannot, and what it costs. Many families combine their own time with online courses, groups and a tutor for one or two subjects.

Will it help with anxiety or school refusal?

Many families tell us their child was calmer once the daily pressure of attendance stopped. That is their experience, not a promise, and leaving school does not treat anxiety. Keep your GP and any specialist involved, and plan for rest first: after a hard time at school, a few quiet weeks are often what makes learning possible again.

Can we go back to school later?

Yes. You apply for a place through the council or the school in the usual way. A record of what your child has learned at home makes that conversation much easier, so keep one from the first week.

What to do this week

  1. Write down, in one sentence each, what is not working: place, people, pace or work.
  2. Ask the school in writing what it can change, and by when.
  3. Decide whether you are choosing a rest, a reset or a long-term change, and who would be with your child each day.
Sources. Elective home education: departmental guidance for parents (DfE, 2019); Children and Families Act 2014 (requesting an EHC needs assessment); DfE guidance on school attendance and on mental health issues affecting attendance.Reviewed by Carl Morris, Co-founder of Phoenix Tutors and Vice President of The Tutors' Association. Last reviewed 16 November 2026.This page is general information, not legal advice. Rules differ between England, Wales, Scotland and Northern Ireland, and they change.

Want a person to look at it with you?

A private consultation: twenty minutes, free, with Carl, Saif or a consultant.

QuickestWhatsApp+44 7440 496063Message us
Most detailA few linesThree questions. A person on our team reads it and replies.Write to us
In your own timeEmailhello@phoenix-tutors.comEmail us